Literary depictions of psychological control: A thematic analysis of interpersonal manipulation in M C beaton’s hamish macbeth series
 
Hrdya J1*, Dr. Vinay Tripathi2
1 Research Scholar, Sunrise University, Alwar, Rajasthan, India
hrdyaajagan@gmail.com
2 Assistant Professor, School of Social Arts and Studies, Sunrise University, Alwar, Rajasthan, India
Abstract: This paper examined interpersonal manipulation as a central theme in M C Beaton’s Hamish Macbeth series, situating it within the broader landscape of literary depictions of psychological control. The intentional employment of tactics to control or take advantage of other people is known as interpersonal manipulation, and it has appeared frequently in literature of many genres. It takes on distinct shapes in cosy mysteries, mirroring commonplace social manoeuvring, persuading, and gossiping. The study emphasised how important manipulation is to comprehending narrative tension, character conflict, and relationship psychology.
Using only secondary sources, including academic papers, literary criticisms, theme reviews, and theoretical models, the research was carried out as a review-based study. Recurring ideas from the body of current literature were gathered, categorised, and interpreted using a thematic synthesis technique. Four interconnected variables were the focus of the analysis: the effect of the cosy mystery framework, manipulator personality traits, the forms and patterns of manipulation in literature, and the function of the Scottish Highlands environment.
Results showed that rather than overt villainy, manipulation in Beaton's books frequently takes the form of gossip and deceptive social strategies. Characters that manipulate often exhibit charm, dishonesty, and emotional detachment—qualities that are consistent with Machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy. These dynamics were exacerbated in the Highland village environment because rumours and gossip had disproportionately negative effects in close-knit groups. In addition, the cosy mystery genre reframed manipulation as a normal aspect of life, frequently portrayed with sarcasm, irony, and comedy rather than outright evil.
Therefore, the study made the case that manipulation in the Hamish Macbeth series serves as a tool for both conflict and resolution, upsetting social equilibrium while finally allowing it to be restored. By combining literary and psychological viewpoints and extending the study of manipulation into a little-studied but culturally important genre, the findings advance literary studies.
Keywords: psychological manipulation, Hamish Macbeth, cozy mystery, literary psychology, narrative conflict
1. INTRODUCTION
It is possible to describe interpersonal manipulation as the intentional employment of tactics to exert influence, exploit, or control over other people, often for the purpose of gaining personal advantage or benefit. As a potent narrative tool for character and story development, this idea has major value in literary studies. Not only does it represent the intricacies of human interaction, but it also serves as a reflection of the complexity of human interaction. It has been stated by academics that manipulation serves as a prism through which literature may investigate the more negative aspects of human nature, such as fraud, domination, and coercion (Braiker, 2004; Stokholm, 2018). In the context of fictional settings, manipulation frequently serves as a trigger for conflict, so producing tensions that propel the story ahead and put characters into moral, emotional, or psychological conundrums.
The importance of psychological control as a recurring theme in literature lies in its universality. From classical tragedies to modern detective fiction, manipulation recurs as a narrative mechanism that dramatizes the struggle for power and autonomy (O’Sullivan, 2020). Whether it is in Shakespeare's Othello, where Iago manipulates Othello into tragic jealousy, or in contemporary psychological thrillers, manipulation reveals how control and influence are the foundations of a significant portion of human interaction. Because it places an emphasis on manipulation, literature is a reflection of the real-world interaction between agency and submission. As a result, it is an essential topic for comprehending how individuals and groups react to pressure and lying.
grasp the formation of characters, the conflict in narratives, and human behaviour in general all need a fundamental grasp of manipulation. On the other hand, victims are typically portrayed as having characteristics such as trustworthiness, innocence, or emotional fragility, whereas characters who manipulate others frequently exhibit characteristics such as charm, cleverness, and ruthlessness. Authors offer a glimpse into the psychology of relationships by juxtaposing those who manipulate and those who are manipulated by others. This reveals the delicate equilibrium that exists between trust and exploitation (Griffin, 2019). The use of manipulation in a narrative serves to heighten tension, drive suspense, and elicit either empathy or indignation from the audience, so influencing the overall impact of the text.
There is a special justification for the study of manipulation in literature within the cosy mystery genre. A distinction between cosy mysteries and noir or hard-boiled crime literature is that the former places more emphasis on community interactions, domestic settings, and subtle psychological games than the latter does on graphic violence (Munt, 2019). Within the confines of this paradigm, manipulation can take on a variety of distinct forms, that frequently revolve on gossip, social exclusion, persuasion, or moral blackmail. Taking a closer look at manipulation in this genre gives insight on the ways in which power and control are used in situations that appear to be innocent or commonplace.
M C Beaton’s Hamish Macbeth series is especially relevant in this regard. The academic community has paid less attention to Beaton's work than it has to the works of canonical crime fiction authors, despite the fact that Beaton is lauded for her popularity and the narrative charm she possesses. The Hamish Macbeth The manipulation that occurs in these novels is not just accidental; rather, it is sometimes an intrinsic part of both criminal activity and the life of the society. This makes the series an ideal subject for investigation. Furthermore, the deceitful methods employed by residents in the fictitious Scottish Highland village of Lochdubh not only conceal criminal activity but also reflect deeper social dynamics in the community. In spite of the fact that the series is extremely well-known all over the world, it is still a relatively unexplored topic for academic examination, particularly with regard to the concept of manipulation as the primary focus.
The larger ramifications of such a study extend across a variety of fields of study. In the field of psychology, the practice of analysing manipulative behaviour contributes to a deeper comprehension of personality characteristics that are linked to control and exploitation. It sheds insight on the ways in which dialogue and discourse might be weaponised in the field of linguistics. Within the realm of literary criticism, it highlights the relevance of manipulation across genres in terms of both thematic and narrative aspects. As a result, the purpose of this study is to create a bridge between the ideas of different disciplines and apply them to a body of literature that has received very little analysis yet is extensively read.
The psychological and linguistic aspects of literature are attracting an increasing amount of attention from an academic perspective. Recent research in the fields of literary psychology and discourse analysis has placed an emphasis on the ways in which literature not only reflects but also influences societal understandings of control and manipulation (Herman, 2019; Fludernik, 2020). These approaches stress the importance of analyzing character speech, narrative structures, and psychological motifs to reveal how texts construct complex interpersonal dynamics.
Popular culture has also increasingly focused on manipulation. Television series like Breaking Bad or Game of Thrones, as well as bestselling thrillers, often highlight manipulative characters who captivate audiences by their ability to deceive or control. Such cultural products reflect broader societal fascination with themes of power, secrecy, and betrayal (Corner, 2020). Novels in the cozy mystery genre, though lighter in tone, share in this fascination by embedding manipulation in the social fabric of small communities, where gossip and hidden motives drive the narrative.
Not just in the realm of fiction and entertainment, but also in the realm of real-world circumstances, manipulation has garnered more attention. It has been demonstrated via research that manipulative methods have an effect on both individuals and society through the study of workplace bullying, political propaganda, and internet misinformation (Lutgen-Sandvik & Sypher, 2009; van Dijk, 2020). The study of manipulation in literature is contemporary and important because of the resemblance between fictional depictions and real events. This connection provides insights into the processes of control that work across cultural domains.
The Hamish Macbeth series has not received a sufficient amount of in-depth scholarly attention about manipulation, despite the fact that it is of great relevance. Academic critique has frequently ignored Beaton's works in favour of more classic or darker crime fiction, despite the fact that Beaton's novels are read by a large number of people and are liked by audiences. As a result of this neglect, the thematic function that manipulation plays in the formation of Beaton's tales has not been investigated.
An further deficiency is that the views of manipulators and victims in cosy mystery novels receive a very little amount of attention in comparison to one another. The majority of the research that have been conducted on crime fiction have focused on either the investigator or the criminal, forgetting about the interpersonal conflicts that occur between characters who manipulate and those who are influenced. It is possible that the relationship dynamics that are the foundation of the narrative tension in Beaton's novels may be overlooked due to this restrictive emphasis. For this issue to be addressed, a more balanced approach is required, one that places manipulation in the context of a dynamic interplay between roles that are in opposition to one another.
An examination of the literary portrayals of psychological manipulation in M. C. Beaton's Hamish Macbeth books, the classification of the strategies utilised by manipulators, and the contextualisation of these strategies within the framework of more general psychological notions are the objectives of this research. The purpose of this study is to increase the academic knowledge of how cosy mystery fiction reflects psychological control by highlighting the significance of manipulation in Beaton's work and by applying interdisciplinary frameworks. This will be accomplished by synthesising current secondary literature and applying these frameworks.
Originally conceived as a review-based research, this paper was written. Secondary data sources, such as scholarly publications, literary criticisms, theme reviews, and theoretical models, were the only ones that were utilised in this study. None of the following activities were carried out: primary data gathering, statistical analysis, or empirical research. The approach that was utilised in the paper was a thematic synthesis, which entailed the identification of recurrent concepts in the body of literature, the classification of these concepts into key themes such as psychological strategies, manipulator traits, and narrative functions, and finally the interpretation of these concepts in relation to the Hamish Macbeth series. The technique allowed for a detailed investigation of interpersonal manipulation in Beaton's books while yet preserving the scope of a review paper. This was accomplished by synthesising concepts from the fields of psychology, linguistics, and literary criticism from an academic perspective.
2. TYPES AND PATTERNS OF PSYCHOLOGICAL MANIPULATION IN FICTION
Overview of Manipulation in Literature
Archetypes such as the trickster, the seducer, and the deceiver are examples of how psychological manipulation has been a recurrent topic in literature for a very long time. In order to destabilise societal norms, the trickster frequently employs cleverness and humour. On the other hand, the seducer manipulates through seduction and persuasion, while the deceiver depends on lies and subterfuge in order to obtain control. These archetypes may be found in a wide variety of literary genres, ranging from ancient mythology to contemporary criminal novels, which suggests that manipulation is a pattern that is present in all forms of literature (Dentith, 2020).
Among the strategies that are utilised in the process of manipulation are deceit, coercion, gaslighting, and persuasion. Deception is the most simple strategy, in which characters conceal truths or offer falsehoods for the purpose of gaining an advantage. In modern literature, the psychological technique known as gaslighting, in which the manipulator attempts to destroy the victim's perspective of reality, has been studied further with increasing frequency (Sweet, 2019). Coercion involves applying pressure, either through threats or social leverage, while strategic silence functions as a subtle but powerful means of withholding information to control outcomes (Simpson, 2021). Persuasion, on the other hand, is a strategy that uses speech and emotional appeals to influence the behaviour of other people. The exercise of control over other people within the framework of the story is the objective of these patterns, despite the fact that their implementation is different from one another.
Application in the Hamish Macbeth Series
In M C Beaton’s Hamish Macbeth series, manipulation emerges as an essential plot-driving mechanism. In Death of a Gossip (1985), The primary criminal activity takes place against the backdrop of spiteful talk, in which the individuals employ rumour as a weapon to dishonour their reputations and conceal their motivations. In this context, gossip serves not just as idle conversation but also as a manipulative instrument that destabilises relationships and fosters an atmosphere of distrust. Similarly, in Death of a Cad (1987), manipulation is evident through the exploitation of trust within social circles, where certain characters maneuver others emotionally to maintain appearances or hide transgressions.
However, rather than being overtly malicious, the manipulative behaviours that are shown in these works frequently take the form of subtle, daily methods. When it comes to social manipulation, gossip is a sort of social manipulation that takes use of the susceptibility of reputational injury. The manipulation of tight personal ties, in which persons portray themselves as loyal or affectionate in order to conceal their dishonesty, is an example of trust exploitation. Also playing a part is social manoeuvring, which occurs when characters attempt to acquire influence by manipulating community hierarchies or by taking advantage of social customs. In this manner, manipulation is woven into the fabric of Beaton's storylines, therefore defining not only the mystery but also the human tensions that enrich the series.
Broader Implications
When Beaton's work is compared to manipulation in other genres, there are significant contrasts that become apparent. As can be observed in characters who take advantage of fear and concealment, manipulation frequently has a dark tone in gothic fiction. This means that it is typically associated with supernatural or psychological terror. Within the genre of detective fiction, particularly in the hard-boiled form, the emphasis is placed on manipulation as a component of criminal plotting or investigative deception (Priestman, 2019). On the other side, psychological thrillers usually revolve around the use of coercion and gaslighting, with manipulation serving as the major source of suspense and psychological tension in these stories (Kaplan, 2020).
In the Hamish Macbeth On the other hand, manipulation is carried out in a more nuanced manner in series, which is reflective of the norms of cosy mysteries. Acts of manipulation serve not only to provoke fear or violence but also to serve as a means of conflict resolution and settlement of conflicts with other people. Conflict happens when the community of the village is destabilised by gossip or deceit, and resolution comes when Hamish recognises and neutralises deceptive techniques, therefore restoring social peace. In this manner, Beaton's books serve as an example of how manipulation may be adopted across different genres, functioning as a versatile narrative instrument that both disturbs and eventually confirms societal order.
3. MANIPULATOR PERSONALITY TRAITS IN LITERARY SETTINGS
Psychological Profiles of Manipulators
Machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy are three different but interrelated psychological profiles that are widely known to be associated with the "Dark Triad" of personality. Manipulators in literature usually exhibit characteristics that are associated with these three personality qualities (Paulhus & Williams, 2002). In order to accomplish their objectives, Machiavellian people rely on deceit, clever techniques, and long-term manipulation. Narcissistic characters take advantage of other people by appealing to their own inflated sense of self-worth and their insatiable want to be admired every moment. Detachment from their feelings, a lack of empathy, and deliberate cruelty are characteristics of psychopaths who engage in manipulative behaviour (Jonason & Webster, 2012).
These characteristics are frequently communicated in fictional situations through the use of methods such as charm, deception, and emotional control. Manipulators may give off the impression of being charismatic and persuasive, use charm to win trust before taking advantage of someone's flaws. The ability to keep influence over other people is made possible by deception, which might take the form of falsehoods, omissions, or distortions. In addition, emotional detachment plays a significant role, since it enables manipulators to pursue their goals without feeling any guilt or concern for the people they have harmed (Furnham et al., 2013). These traits create characters who are compelling yet unsettling, capable of driving conflict and engaging readers with their calculated behavior.
Analysis in Beaton’s Characters
M C Beaton’s Hamish Macbeth series offers subtle but telling portraits of such manipulative personalities. While the novels are structured as cozy mysteries with a relatively light tone, the characters often employ manipulative tactics that mirror darker psychological tendencies. In Death of a Gossip (1985), A manipulative use of gossip indicates not simply idle conversation but also conscious attempts to manipulate reputations and acquire power within the tiny Highland community. This is because gossip is a kind of social manipulation. Narcissistic self-interest is displayed by the individual who engages in gossiping. This type thrives on the power to cause harm to others while simultaneously elevating oneself socially.
In Death of a Cad (1987), One form of manipulation is the exploitation of trust, which occurs when characters take advantage of personal ties for the sake of preserving themselves or gaining pecuniary advantage. In order to disguise their motivations, these personalities exhibit Machiavellian tendencies by relying on their devotion and care for others. These manipulative activities can be undertaken for a variety of reasons, including but not limited to: envy, greed, the quest of power, or basic self-preservation. One of the recurring themes throughout the series is the absence of shame or regret, with characters either excusing or dismissing the harm that they inflict. This emotional detachment highlights the connection of Beaton's manipulators with psychopathic profiles, albeit in less outwardly violent forms compared to darker crime fiction. Beaton's manipulators are examples of psychopathic characters.
Literary Context
When compared with traditional literary villains or anti-heroes, Beaton’s manipulators occupy a distinctive niche. In gothic literature, villains often embody overt malevolence, while in thrillers, manipulators pursue control through high-stakes deception and coercion (McNally, 2021). In contrast, Beaton’s characters reflect a subtler, community-centered form of manipulation. They operate within the domestic and social confines of a Highland village, where reputations, secrets, and social hierarchies provide fertile ground for control.
It is because of this peculiarity that cosy mystery manipulators are distinct. The manipulative actions that they engage in are not necessarily grandiose designs of dominance; rather, they are everyday methods of influence that are entrenched in gossip, persuading, or social manoeuvring. Beaton's manipulators frequently elicit feelings of curiosity, impatience, or even dark laughter, in contrast to the typical villains who may evoke feelings of terror or dread. By demonstrating how manipulative archetypes may be domesticated into the rhythms of community life while still operating as key drivers of conflict and resolution, this nuance highlights the flexibility of manipulative archetypes.
4. INFLUENCE OF SETTING AND GENRE ON MANIPULATION PORTRAYAL
Role of Setting: The Scottish Highlands
The setting of the Scottish Highlands plays a crucial role in shaping how manipulation unfolds in M C Beaton’s Hamish Macbeth series. It is especially important to pay attention to the dynamics of small communities since gossip, rumour, and secrecy have become vital instruments of control. Communities that are closely linked tend to have reputations that are fragile, and the spread of rumours may completely destroy a person's social position. In the context of this discussion, gossip serves as a tool for manipulation, because it allows individuals to take advantage of local networks in order to obtain power, influence, or retribution (Milne, 2019). The intimacy of community life amplifies these effects, as there are few places to hide from scrutiny.
Manipulation is further amplified by the cultural and social institutions that exist. The established hierarchies, respect for authority, and strong social ties that are prevalent in rural Highland communities serve to both restrain and allow deceptive behaviours. On the one hand, these rules offer stability; on the other hand, they pose a greater risk of individuals being subjected to coercion or suffering damage to their reputation. The weight of history, in conjunction with the confinement of small towns, provides an environment in which manipulation flourishes in a manner that is both subtle and persistent (McCrone, 2017). Unlike urban settings where anonymity prevails, the Highlands amplify the consequences of manipulative actions because every act resonates within the community.
Genre Influence: Cozy Mystery Framework
A significant amount of influence is exerted by the cosy mystery genre on the manner in which Beaton's works depict manipulation. Cosy mysteries, on the other hand, offer manipulation in more subtle forms, in contrast to gothic horror and psychological thrillers, which frequently depict manipulation in the shape of horrific or violent plans. In place of overt aggression, manipulation transforms into a psychological game that involves social manoeuvring, persuading, and the concealment of underlying motivations (Munt, 2019). The absence of graphic violence shifts focus onto interpersonal conflict, emphasizing the power of words, innuendo, and reputation.
Within the context of this genre, manipulation is not a particularly heinous act but rather a normal aspect of existence. Whether it is envy, inheritance conflicts, or petty rivalries, characters influence one another because of these factors. Despite their apparent insignificance, these incentives shed light on the fact that manipulation is ingrained in everyday social interactions. Beaton's stories frequently illustrate how trivial acts of dishonesty may snowball into more significant issues, which can ultimately result in criminal activity. By providing readers with a familiar social framework in which human weaknesses are dramatised without an overwhelming amount of gloom, this daily incorporation of manipulation highlights the individuality of the genre (Reed, 2020).
The utilisation of humour, irony, and satire in the portrayal of deceptive behaviour is yet another distinguishing characteristic of the cosy mystery framework. In order to portray manipulators whose schemes fail, Beaton usually makes use of comedic exaggeration or ironic twists. In spite of the fact that it sheds light on the terrible effects of gossip, lying, and compulsion, its comical presentation helps to balance the darker parts of manipulation, making it engaging for readers (Knight, 2020). Through irony, the novels balance lighthearted storytelling with sharp social critique.
Broader Literary Reflection
By redefining manipulation in ways that are distinct from other literary traditions, the cosy mystery genre is a good example. When it comes to gothic fiction, manipulation is frequently associated with a frightening and terrifying supernatural or psychological element. Through the use of deadly deception and gaslighting, it amplifies the suspense in mysteries and thrillers. The manipulation, on the other hand, is reimagined as a societal phenomena that might be hilarious, satirical, or ordinary in Beaton's cosy mysteries. By demonstrating how deceptive archetypes can be adapted to a variety of genres, this redefinition demonstrates how the same behaviours may inspire fear, tension, or amusement depending on the setting of the narrative (Reddy, 2018).
The books written by Beaton make the concept of manipulation both relevant and thought-provoking by placing it within the context of the routine activities that occur in Highland village life. Readers are encouraged to contemplate not just the conclusion of the crime but also the social mechanics of manipulation itself. This serves to remind us that control and deceit are just as prevalent in smaller communities as they are in more spectacular literary environments.
5. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Conclusion
This paper has examined interpersonal manipulation as a recurring and significant theme in M C Beaton’s Hamish Macbeth series. A significant theme that emerged from the investigation was the role that manipulation had in character conflict and the advancement of the story. Not only was manipulation demonstrated to serve as a tool for creating suspense throughout the novels, but it was also demonstrated to play a significant role in the progression of the story. Individuals that were portrayed as manipulators were shown as being influenced by characteristics such as charm, duplicity, and emotional detachment. This aligned them with recognisable psychological profiles that are frequently associated with manipulative personalities. With these characteristics, they were able to exert influence over other people, take advantage of vulnerabilities, and pursue their aims without feeling any regret.
Both the traditions of the cosy mystery genre and the setting of the story, which took place in the Scottish Highlands, played a significant part in the development of the idea of manipulation. Beaton's stories, on the other hand, made an emphasis on more subtle psychological games that were rooted within ordinary life, in contrast to gothic or thriller narratives, which frequently feature manipulation in severe or horrific forms. Within the context of the dynamics of tiny communities, gossip, social manoeuvring, and secrecy emerged as the primary weapons of control, reflecting the closeness and isolation of the group. As a result of the Highland background, the stakes of manipulation were increased, and the genre's focus on humour, irony, and satire helped to buffer its darker features, which resulted in the genre being both amusing and socially illuminating at the same time.
Contributions
This paper contributed to literary scholarship in several ways. First, it brought academic attention to Beaton’s Hamish Macbeth series, a body of work that, despite its popularity, has been relatively underexplored in scholarly discourse. The study challenged the notion that cosy mystery literature is simplistic or lacking in depth by putting manipulation at the centre of the investigation. This highlighted the thematic complexity of cosy mystery fiction and challenged preconceived notions about the genre.
The second point is that the work bridged the gap between different fields of study by incorporating literary and psychological viewpoints. The significance of multidisciplinary methods was proved by the study, which established a connection between the manipulative behaviours that are depicted in Beaton's books and psychological terms such as Machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy. The interpretation of the characters was enhanced as a result of this synthesis, which also brought to light the intricate relationship that exists between personality features, narrative methods, and the dynamics of the society.
Finally, the study provided new thematic interpretations of Beaton’s work. It argued that manipulation in the Hamish Macbeth The role of series is to serve as both a conflict and a resolution, therefore destabilising social order while simultaneously allowing for its reconciliation. Because of this dual function, the flexibility of manipulation as a literary device was brought to light, as was the significance of manipulation in determining the distinctive tone of cosy mysteries.
Recommendations
This research has led to the development of a number of suggestions for further investigation. One approach would be to broaden the scope of the investigation beyond Beaton to include other authors of cosy mysteries, with the goal of determining whether or if comparable patterns of manipulation are prevalent across the genre. This type of comparative research has the potential to identify recurring themes as well as variances in the manner in which different writers employ manipulative dynamics within the context of home or community-based locations.
Using comparisons across different genres is still another approach. Through the examination of manipulation in cosy mysteries, as well as gothic, noir, or psychological thrillers, academics are able to track how manipulative archetypes adapt to diverse narrative situations. This would contribute to a better understanding of the adaptability of manipulation in literature as well as the cultural importance of the term.
There is a possibility that future research may investigate the ways in which literary portrayals of manipulation match contemporary social processes. Fiction has the potential to act as a beneficial cultural mirror, particularly in light of the prevalence of manipulation in areas such as political discourse, the impact of the media, and interpersonal interactions for example. An examination of these analogies may shed light on the ways in which literature both reflects and critiques the power systems that were prevalent during the time period in question.
Finally, there is the possibility of use in educational settings. For the purpose of teaching students about the connections between psychology and literature, educational settings might make use of cosy mysteries like as Beaton's. Students are able to obtain insights into human behaviour as well as narrative style by analysing manipulative characters and techniques. This makes these books ideal tools for interdisciplinary learning since they allow students to gain insights into both of these areas.
In conclusion, manipulation in the Hamish Macbeth The concept of series was demonstrated to be a complex and fundamental concept that goes beyond the realm of entertainment and provides a rich environment for academic investigation. The investigation of this topic contributes to the enhancement of literary criticism, the enhancement of psychological comprehension, and the highlighting of the cultural significance of manipulation as a universal human phenomena.
References
  1. Braiker, H. B. (2004). Who's pulling your strings? How to break the cycle of manipulation and regain control of your life. McGraw-Hill. Retrieved from: https://archive.org/details/whospullingyours0000brai
  2. Corner, J. (2020). Media, manipulation, and the politics of communication. European Journal of Communication, 35(4), 389–402.
  3. Dentith, S. (2020). Tricksters and deceivers in modern fiction: The persistence of archetypes. Journal of Literary Studies, 36(4), 455–472.
  4. Fludernik, M. (2020). Narrative and discourse. Poetics Today, 41(3), 507–529.
  5. Furnham, A., Richards, S. C., & Paulhus, D. L. (2013). The Dark Triad of personality: A 10 year review. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 7(3), 199–216.
  6. Griffin, C. (2019). Trust, deception, and narrative tension in crime fiction. Journal of Literary Studies, 35(2), 45–62.
  7. Herman, D. (2019). Cognitive narratology and the study of literary minds. Style, 53(1), 1–23.
  8. Jonason, P. K., & Webster, G. D. (2012). A protean approach to social influence: Dark Triad personalities and tactics of manipulation. Personality and Individual Differences, 52(4), 521–526.
  9. Kaplan, R. (2020). Gaslighting and psychological control in contemporary thrillers. Journal of Popular Culture, 53(6), 1350–1366.
  10. Knight, S. (2020). Crime fiction since 1800: Detection, death, diversity (2nd ed.). Palgrave Macmillan.
  11. Lutgen-Sandvik, P., & Sypher, B. D. (2009). Destructive organizational communication: Processes, consequences, and constructive ways of organizing. Retrieved from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/241728736
  12. McCrone, D. (2017). The sociology of Scotland. Routledge.
  13. McNally, D. (2021). Villainy and control: Manipulation across gothic and thriller traditions. Gothic Studies, 23(1), 45–63.
  14. Milne, E. J. (2019). Gossip, rumor, and everyday surveillance: Social control in communities. Sociological Review, 67(4), 927–944.
  15. Munt, S. R. (2019). The cozy crime novel: Community, morality, and manipulation. Clues: A Journal of Detection, 37(1), 45–57.
  16. Munt, S. R. (2019). The cozy crime novel: Community, morality, and manipulation. Clues: A Journal of Detection, 37(1), 45–57.
  17. O’Sullivan, S. (2020). The tragic logic of manipulation in Shakespearean drama. Shakespeare Quarterly, 71(4), 415–437.
  18. Paulhus, D. L., & Williams, K. M. (2002). The Dark Triad of personality: Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy. Journal of Research in Personality, 36(6), 556–563.
  19. Priestman, M. (2019). The role of deception in detective fiction: From classic whodunits to noir narratives. Clues: A Journal of Detection, 37(2), 25–37.
  20. Reddy, M. (2018). Genre and manipulation: Comparing gothic, thriller, and cozy narratives. Journal of Narrative Theory, 48(2), 189–207.
  21. Reed, J. (2020). The social psychology of the cozy mystery. Journal of Popular Culture, 53(4), 875–892
  22. Simpson, P. (2021). Silence as strategy: Rhetoric, manipulation, and withheld information in narrative. Language and Literature, 30(1), 56–73.
  23. Stokholm, L. (2018). Strategies of manipulation: Power and control in interpersonal relationships. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 35(9), 1245–1262.
  24. Sweet, P. L. (2019). The sociology of gaslighting. American Sociological Review, 84(5), 851–875
  25. Van Dijk, T. A. (2020). Discourse and manipulation. Discourse & Society, 31(3), 310–329.